Mixed Matings

(Note: This story is part of an ongoing series of Fairy Tail stories)
Previous Story (Part XI): [LINK]
Beginning (Part I): [LINK]
Next Story (Part XIII): [LINK]

---

“Ugh… What a week…!” Lucy and Juvia sighed in unison as they leaned back in their chairs. But while Lucy sounded as if she was truly exhausted and in dire need of some much needed sleep, Juvia seemed much more jovial and eager for more.

 

“My, my… Seems like you had quite some fun on your missions the last couple days, Lucy.” Erza mentioned from the side as she joined her two friends on the table. Her eyes lingered on Juvia for only a second before she turned her attention to Lucy. “Got any luck with your missions?”

 

Lucy waved her friend’s question off, “Don’t ask. If the photos we took for that special edition of the Sorcerer Magazine aren’t enough…” she began, only to stop and let out an even more sorrowful sigh than before. “The money Natsu and I got for that quest from that Ugly Bastard should definitely be enough to pay the bills!”

 

“Special edition of the Sorcerer Magazine? And a quest from an Ugly Bastard?” Erza echoed with a raised eyebrow as she silently ordered something to drink from Mirajane. “Seems like you two had a really rough time there. Speaking of, where is Natsu anyways? I don’t see him anywhere.”

 

“Honestly, I’m not sure…” Lucy shook her head as she downed the rest of her drink in one go. “We went home together, but he didn’t seem willing to talk about anything that happened between him and Flare. Part of me is actually happy about it… I’m not sure if I wanna know what that girl wanted from him!”

 

“Flare was there as well?” Raising an eyebrow, Juvia edged closer towards Lucy. “Now Juvia really wants to learn more! Is she a rival as well?”

 

“A rival? What rival?” Lucy asked back, more than just a little puzzled by the bluette’s strange remark.

 

“Oh, erm… nevermind!” Juvia replied, with her face now burning with the same intensity as Erza’s hair. “But… I… I guess that means that Natsu-san probably needs someone to cheer him up then, right?”

 

Nudging her in the side, Erza forced Juvia to squeal in a girlish way that made her open for an arm being thrown over her shoulder, “Don’t tell me you’re already eager for some more… exploration?!” the older woman teased the former enemy. “Didn’t you come back from Fortune City only this morning?”

 

“ERZA! Not so loud!” the young water mage hissed silently, but loud enough for Lucy to still hear her.

 

“Fortune City? Don’t tell me you’ve been there as well?” She took a new glass from Mirajane in exchange for the old one. “I thought only Levy went there to win some money in the casinos and to do some dancing in the clubs there.”

 

Before Juvia could give her an answer however, Erza moved between the two girls and put a hand on each of their shoulders, “Say, girls… Why don’t we three go and have some fun?

 

Lucy, you really look like you could use some distraction from your missions, and from what you’ve told us, Natsu too.” She then turned her attention towards Juvia and squeezed her shoulder a bit harder. “And I think I know exactly what you need! Also, feel free to invite Gray as well?”

 

Lucy and Juvia gulped at the same time as they exchanged concerned, yet intriguing, looks. “What do you have in mind?”

 

---

 

(Sometime later…)

 

“Gray? What the heck are you doing here?” Natsu asked the dark haired mage who had just stumbled out of the bushes to his left and onto the dirty path where Natsu was walking on for the last hour or so.

 

“I was called here by Juvia.” he explained after a brief second of confusion upon seeing his best friend/rival. “She wrote me a letter that I should meet her at this waterfall at the heart of the forest. Told me that she has a surprise for me.”

 

“Weird…” scratching the back of his head, Natsu turned around in search of clues or something that would help him understand what was going on. “Lucy wrote me basically the same letter! That I should let Happy have some rest and come alone so that she can make me forget all about my worries.”

 

“I guess Erza came up with something again.” a familiar third voice chimed in. Dropping down from a nearby tree, Jellal landed between a perplexed Natsu and a baffled Gray who couldn’t seem to believe their eyes. “Otherwise she wouldn’t have invited all three of us to come here at the same time!”

 

“Je- Jellal? What are you doing here?” Gray asked, being the first of the two Fairy Tail mages to regain his ability to speak, “Aren’t you doing missions with Crime Sorcière anymore?” he asked as Jellal walked past them.

 

He nodded, “Initially, yes. But a few days ago I met Erza and ever since then she wanted to hang out and spend more time together.” scratching the back of his head, Jellal took the lead as the other two men followed him deeper into the woods. “We went to Fortune City and… Yeah! This has to be Erza’s idea, no doubt about it!”

 

Together, the three men continued walking silently for another fifteen minutes or so until they finally heard the rushing of water. In these parts of the forest, the air was much more humid, due to the constant spray of the waterfall everywhere. Leaves, moss, rocks… Everything was a few hues darker because of the water, making the three mages instantly forget about how unbelievably hot it was outside of the cooling shadows of the forest. The buzzing sound of dragonflies and other insects in the air was only barely noticeable over roaring water as it fell from a ten meter high cliff into a lake that could be more accurately described as an oversized pond.

 

And standing right in front of this spectacular sight were the three girls that had called them here!

 

“Finally! I almost thought you wouldn’t find your way here!” Erza called out to the three men.

 

“Erm… I… you… we… Ermmmm…!!” Gray and Natsu stammered as their faces quickly heated up upon seeing Erza, Juvia, and Erza standing almost completely naked in front of them.

 

Their only “clothes” consisted of three identical red thongs that dug deep into the folds of their already soaking pussies. If due to excitement or because of the waterfall, neither of the men knew, nor did they care as their eyes were automatically pulled further up and towards three tattoos right underneath their belly buttons. A flame for Lucy, a snowflake for Juvia, and the insignia of the Fairy Tail Guild for Erza. In Erza’s case, she even added a second tattoo over her right tit that looked almost identical to the mark Jellal had when he was still possessed and their enemy. To top it all off, each girl wore heart-shaped panties that tried to hide their nipples, but failed desperately as their areolas, and even most of her already stiff nipples in Erza’s particular case, were clearly visible for the guys.

 

“Erza, to what do we owe this pleasure?” asked Jellal. A soft smile curled around his lips as he already walked further onward to meet the trio of girls. Unlike the other two men at his side, he already became more than familiar with the ginger haired girl’s more perverted nature the last couple days.

 

Throwing her hands behind Lucy’s and Juvia’s back, Erza pulled them closer towards her, “Not much. We talked for a bit and found out that we all really could need something to take our minds off of any monetary issues or other problems we might have.” she explained with a giggle as she felt the weight of the other girls’ tits on her own chest.

 

“Mhm!” Juvia agreed with the S-Class mage as she pressed her body against Erza’s.

 

“We even already came up with a way to determine who gets to fuck who!” Lucy added with a wink at Gray as she raised her fist into the air. “We drew lots!”

 

“Lots?” all three guys echoed at once, more than just a bit confused by how peaceful and harmonic the three girls operated. Usually, Juvia would be furious at the other girls for being so naked around HER Gray-sama!

 

“Yeah! And that means…” Erza smirked as she pulled a condom, labeled as XL, from behind the strap of her thong, “That this… belongs to me!” she whispered hoarsely as she grabbed Natsu’s cock through the fabric of his loose sitting pants!

 

“Oooooah…!!” In an instant, Natsu became stiff as a board and found himself unable to resist Erza’s feminine touch.

 

“Lucy told me all about how big your friend down there can become, so I guess it’s only fitting that I would be the one to take care of it for you, right?” Erza cooed lecherously while leading him away from the others.

 

With Natsu’s grunts of rising pleasure growing more and more silent every second, Lucy and Juvia strutted forth. They swung their hips from side to side as they reached for Gray’s and Jellal’s hands. “Come on, boys! Are you up for some fun?”

 

---

 

(Natsu X Erza)

 

“FUCK!!!” Sweat pearled down Natsu’s neck as he found Erza’s lips tightening around his dick with every inch she took down her throat. Her own neck was visibly distended because of his enormous size. “So… TIGHT!!!!”

 

She smiled up at him, seemingly unbothered by his girth whatsoever, “Hehehehehegh… What’sh da mattew, Natshu?” She took his cock to the halfway point and held it there for several long seconds, with her tongue lashing all over the behemoth inside her mouth. “Aye phought ‘ou wanted ‘oo depheat meeeh…”

 

Grunting, Natsu’s hands sunk into the wet moss beneath him as he leaned back against the tree behind him, “Urrgh… not now…” he groaned lowly while throwing his hips back and forth in a slow rhythm. “That girl… Flare… We did things together…” A shudder went down his spine as he looked past the branches and leaves of the oak above him.

 

“MMMMMHH!!!! Sheemsh wike she didh quite a numbah on ‘ou…!” Erza giggled around his cock, with the vibrations of her words echoing through the pink haired man’s entire body. “Then aye beddah mageh shuwe ‘ou phoged aww awbout hew!! HMM, MMMH, MMMMH, GULLL, HMMM, MMMMMPH, UUUUMMH, MMMMUPH!!!!!!”

 

“AAAAAHH… ERZA!!!!!” Natsu roared as his friend rapidly worked her way down his length. Within seconds, ten inches of his cock disappeared behind the S-Class mage’s lips as she greedily sucked and licked him as if he was the most delicious strawberry cake in the world!

 

“MMMMHH!!! SHO GHUUDDD!!! AYE COUWD SHUGG DISH CAWK EVEWYDAY!!!!” she moaned, as her words badly slurred and barely understandable as her jaw was stretched to the absolute limit. “GUUUUH, HUMMMMM, HMMMMPH, UUUUUMUUGH!!!!”

 

Everytime she pulled her head back again, her lips would cling to his rock hard shaft and drag behind in the most erotic way possible. A warmth spread through the thin layer of the condom around his cock that made him instantly forget about the day with Flare prior.

 

A soft grin curled around the edges of his mouth, “Hrrrr… You’re doing this good, Erza!” he groaned from deep in his stomach as he stroked her silky red hair with one hand.

 

“That’sh mowe wike iddd!!!” Erza slurred supportively while leaning her head softly against the palm of his hand. “‘ou phink ‘ou couwd phugg muh phace wiph that cawk now?”

 

“Could I?!” Natsu’s eyes lit up somewhat as he pushed himself up from the mossy bed beneath him. He placed both hands on either side of Erza’s face and pulled his cock back until only the first ten inches were left inside. “Compared to Flare, this will be a blast!”

 

“HA! I’d wike to shee ‘ou twYIEEEEEEEEH!!!!” countless birds flew off into the distance in response to Erza’s high pitched squeal of surprise and pleasure, “UUUUUGH, GULLLLUR, UURRRRK, UUG, UUG, UGG!!!!!” the ginger haired girl moaned wetly as Natsu piston-fucked her face with newly found energy!

 

“Haaa, haaaa, haaaaa…!! That’s it! Take it like the SLUT you actually are, Erza!!” Natsu demanded as he watched her eyes roll back into their sockets. With every thrust, her eyelids fluttered as more and more saliva flung in every direction. “I’M SO FIRED UP RIGHT NOW!!!”

 

“AYE… OOOOOOAGH… AYE CAN PHEEW IDD!!!!” agreed Erza. She could feel her own saliva evaporate in her mouth as the temperature of Natsu’s cock rose with each thrust. “CUUMMMM… CUMM IN MUH MOUPH, NATSHU!!!! GIMME ‘OUW JISSSH!!!!!!”

 

“HEHEHEHEHE!!! You got it!!” Natsu obliged as he pulled her face all the way into his crotch. “I’ll make sure that you’re never be able to taste another dick than mine ever AGAIIIIIIIN!!!!!!!”

 

“UUUULGHEWEEEEEEE!!!!!” Erza closed her eyes in bliss as Natsu’s cum instantly burst through the flimsy excuse of a condom, filling her very stomach to brim in an instant.

 

Earlier than she would have liked, Natsu pulled his hips back again and let go of her face. Followed by a nasty sounding SHLORP, his cock sprung out of her mouth and slapped wetly against her cheek. Tattered remains of the purple condom stuck to her skin, glued there by the sticky cum that still ran out of the dickslit like.

 

“Ahhh, see!? That wasn’t so bad…!” Erza panted as she rubbed her face against his cock like a cat in heat. “But if you actually wanna beat me, you’d have to try WAY harder than that! That was nothing!”

 

“Haahaahaa… if you were that easy to beat, I’d never have declared you my rival!” Natsu retorted with a weak smile, “Hope your ass and pussy can take a pounding!” he said as he flipped her on her back with relative ease. “I’m not gonna stop fucking you until you admit that I’m stronger!”

 

Erza smiled back at him, while already spreading her gushing wet pussy with her index and middle finger. “Let’s put it to the test. Give me your best shot, Dragon Dick!”

 

---

 

(Gray X Lucy)

 

“Ahhh… a little bit down…” moaned Lucy, “Left, left!” she mewled as surges of pleasure coursed from the spot where Gray was currently touching her. “YES!! RIGHT THERE!!!” the blonde bucked her entire body against his hand as he kneaded her sore flesh and muscles a few centimeters left of her spine. “That’s the spo~ot!!!”

 

“Heh. You really are stressed!” Gray mused out loud as his fingers worked to unwind the knots in her body. “Were the last few days that strenuous?”

 

“More than you’d thi~IENK!!” she ended up squealing as something in her body popped due to Gray’s surprisingly skilful attempt at a full-body massage.

 

Even without any massage oil or a table to work with, Gray managed to make her feel relaxed and at ease with nothing but the meadows beneath her naked body and his icy cold hands on her back. The same icy cold hands that currently sunk slightly into her firm flesh as he kneaded her with an expertise that would make some of the employees in the spas she visited from time to time seem like newbies!

 

“I, HAAA!!! I never thought that working as a waitress on top of all these other missions would be so taxinNNNNNNNGH…!!” she admitted as she bit down on her lower lip to stop herself from moaning too loud. Though they were the only ones in the forest, that didn’t mean that she had to scream out from the top of her lungs just because of a massage.

 

“Mhm. I think I know of something that could help you calm down even more.” Gray then said.

 

Lucy smiled inwardly, already having a good idea of his intentions as he pulled her thong down, revealing her moist pussy and eagerly twitching asshole, “Hmmm… Yes! Fuck me! Break me!!” she whispered softly as the tip of his cock already slipped into her butt!

 

Wet squelching noises filled the humid air as Gray began throwing his hips against Lucy’s thighs, “Hrrm, hrrrm, hrrr, huff…!” he groaned silently as his dick found little to no resistance, only slightly scratching her inner walls as he stirred it around. “Damn, Lucy! Someone really riled you up down there!”

 

“AYIE!!! Don’t say it like that!” she hissed at him, her face several hues more red than Erza’s hair as she looked over her shoulder to see Gray massage her ass cheeks softly. “It’s not my fault that Natsu doesn’t know how to hold back!” she moaned.

 

“You know, lesser men would probably feel insecure about a statement like this…” Gray began as he pulled her into a wheelbarrow position. “Luckily, I’m not one of them! In fact, I just might know the trick to make you go off even more!”

 

Blinking, Lucy locked her legs behind Gray’s back to better keep her in this position, “What do you meAAAAAAAAGGGH!!!” she suddenly screamed as a coldness unlike anything she ever experienced before washed over her!

 

Both Gray’s hands and his dick were coated with a thin layer of ice that instantly made her clench all her muscles on pure instinct! In an instant, her pussy felt stuffed to the brim with nothing but Gray’s cock as her inner walls pressed tightly around the invasive member, squeezing it tightly as he began thrusting his entire body against hers for real!

 

“OH GODD!!! FUUUUUCK!!!!” she moaned in utter ecstasy. Her entire body trembled in a mix of pleasure and as a reaction to how cold Gray felt against her, “HOW CAN THIS FEEL SO COLD AND HOT AT THE SAME TIME????” she asked nobody in particular with a voice so loud it had to reach the heavens!

 

“Hehehe… Glad you like this little trick!” Gray groaned approvingly while keeping the pace at a steady rhythm. The PLAP PLAP PLAP PLAP of flesh hitting flesh echoed through the forest, only to be interrupted by another, much louder SLAP!

 

“AYEEEEEE!!!!” Lucy squealed as her butt rippled in response to getting spanked by the dark haired ice mage. “MY ASS!!!! SPANK ME AGAIN!!!! IT MAKES ME CUM SO GOO~D!!”

 

Gray’s answer was another sudden slap, this time on her other cheek, “You sure are a horny one, aren’t you!?” he asked, his eyes practically glued to the blonde’s creamy rear end as it turned red, both because of his spanking and because of how cold his palms were. The longer he held her there, the more pronounced the veins all over her ass became!

 

“SO COLD!!!! BUT… IT FEELS LIKE I’M BURNING UP FROM THE INSIDE!!!!!!” the Celestial Spirit mage screamed and shouted as her legs clamped even tighter behind her partner’s back, keeping him locked inside.

 

“Urrr… Lucy, I’m gonna…!” he moaned through gritted teeth as the pressure in his balls became almost unbearable.

 

Clenching her inner muscles around his icy-hot dick, Lucy managed to give him a warm smile, even though she didn’t see clearly due to her eyes already mostly rolled into the back of her head.

 

“DO IT!!!” she demanded hoarsely. “GIVE ME YOUR CUM!!! FILL MY STOMACH WITH YOUR ICE CREAM!!!!”

 

“AHHAAAAA!!!!” Gray roared with Lucy as his balls couldn’t hold back any longer. A gallon-worth of jizz shot into the condom, filling it completely with a cold and sticky load that made Lucy shudder and shake as if she were on her last breath!

 

No longer able to hold on to him due to her fading strength, Lucy opened her leg-lock around Gray and fell forward. Moss and grass cushioned her fall, embracing her like an old friend. Right as she was about to let out a sigh of relief, Gray fell over her, his cock still buried inside her twitching asshole.

 

“MMMMMMHH…!!!” Lucy moaned contently, enjoying the sensation of the dark haired man’s dick still throbbing inside of her. “Hmmmm, you really know how to make a woman feel good!”

 

---

 

(Jellal X Juvia)

 

“CUM!!! SO MUCH CUMMMMMM!!!! JUVIA LOVES ITTTT!!!!! JUVIA IS IN LOVE WITH ALL THAT CUUUUUUMMM!!!!!!” the bluette hollered louder than the other two girls combined as Jellal pumped his fifth load or so deep into her. The condom she had originally put on his dick laid all but forgotten somewhere to her left, Jellal’s cum still dripping out of it and combining with the other jizz that covered the entire floor!

 

“Urrrgh… you really want to squeeze me dry, do you?!” Jellal asked the younger girl, still pounding his cock in and out of her sopping wet pussy, “Fine! Take it!” he held on to her thighs as his thrusts became slower, yet more powerful!

 

“OH GOD!!! JUVIA IS CUMMING!!!!” she moaned loudly. “MY PUSSY… YOU’RE RUINING MY BODY WITH THAT FUCKING BITCH BREAKER-DICK…!!!” her own fingers sunk somewhat into the firm skin of her tits as she squeezed them roughly. “CUMMINNGH!! CUMCUMCUMCUMCUMCUMCUMCUMCUM!!!!!!!!”

 

Stirring his cock around inside of her, Jellal followed each of her reactions closely, “Hmm! What would Gray think… haaa, haaa, haaa… if he could see you like this!?”

 

“NHOOO!!! GRAY-SAMA CAN’T KNOW WHAT’S HAPPENING HERE!!!!!” Juvia shouted while the world around her spun faster and faster with each slam of Jellal’s hips. “HE… he would think Juvia is nothing but a cheap sluUUUUUUUUTTT!!!!!”

 

“But you are a cheap slut, aren’t you?!” the co-founder of Crime Sorcière whispered hotly into her ears, his muscular chest rubbing against her hands and what little of her tits poked out between her fingers.

 

“YES!!!! JUVIA LIKES THIS FEELING OF A COCK SO DEEP INSIDE OF HER!!!! THE TASTE OF CUM ON HER TONGUE!!! AND THE ACHE IN HER ENTIRE BODY AS YOU FUCK JUVIA TO INSANITY!!!!!!” she answered without hesitation, even though she knew that the others couldn’t be that far off from where she was.

 

Jellal’s thrusts became even slower, “For being so honest, I think you earned yourself a reward!” he groaned before slamming his dick one last time into her cunt!

 

The world at the edge of Juvia’s vision disappeared as Jellal pumped her once more full with his cum. Cum from ten minutes or so got pushed out around his cock as the new load filled her womb to the brim!

 

For a brief second, Juvia’s entire body became stiff as a board as she climaxed with the fellow bluette. Then the moment passed and everything went limp. “MIND… JUVIA is… losing her… miiii…!”

 

---

 

(Story by: Mr. Akrononym)